Types of Writ Petitions in Pakistan

A writ petition is an order given by a higher court to a government official or lower court requiring performance of a specific act, These rights may be individual rights or they may ensure that the governmental system is running appropriately.

Under the Constitution of Pakistan , Supreme Court and High Court are empowered to issue writs, for the enforcement of fundamental rights.
Article 184 – Supreme Court
Article 199 – High Court

Who can file a writ ?

In general, a writ petition is a legal remedy available in common law, and it is a way for individuals to seek relief from the courts when they believe their fundamental rights have been violated.

Writ petitions are commonly filed by individuals, organizations, or entities that have a sufficient legal interest or standing in the matter. Here are some common categories of individuals or entities that may file a writ petition:

  1. Individuals: Any person who believes that their fundamental rights have been violated may file a writ petition. This could include violations of rights such as the right to life, liberty, equality, etc.
  2. Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs): Organizations that are focused on human rights, civil liberties, or other public interest issues may be allowed to file writ petitions on behalf of affected individuals or to address broader societal concerns.
  3. Government Authorities: In some cases, government bodies or officials may file writ petitions. For example, a government agency might file a writ petition to challenge the constitutionality of a law.
  4. Public Interest Litigation (PIL): A Public Interest Litigation, where any citizen or group can file a writ petition on behalf of the public or a class of people, even if they personally are not directly affected.

There are many different writ petitions,

1.Habeas Corpus Latin You may have the body
2.Mandamus Latin We command
3.Prohibition English Stop/ Forbid
4.Certiorari Latin To be Certified
5.Quo Warranto Latin By what Authority

1.Habeas Corpus

Habeas corpus (“produce the body” in Latin) is a writ given to an institution or a prison warden to release an imprisoned person from custody.  This remedy can be pursued by the prisoner or by another person coming to his or her assistance. This keeps a government from imprisoning people unlawfully and protecting rights of individual against arbitrary governmental actions, This is sometimes given when the preservation of life is in danger due to improper jail conditions or other violations.

Grounds: The petitioner alleges that the detention is illegal or that the person is held in violation of fundamental rights.

2.Mandamus

This writ is given to a lower-level court or a government officer to mandate that proper laws are followed. Mandamus might be given if an official is not using his position appropriately or if a court is not following the laws of the state or country. Mandamus is a judicial remedy which is in the form of an order from a superior court to any subordinate court, organization or public authority to do or refrain from doing some specific act which that body is obliged under the law to do or abstain from doing, This writ (also called the “writ of mandate”) ensures that the government and the individuals in charge are performing their functions properly.

Grounds: The petitioner must demonstrate that the duty in question is a legal duty and that there is no alternative remedy available.

To maintain a balance of power and avoid the abuse of power there are certain conditions in which this writ cannot be issued.

  1. cannot be issued against the government to perform non-statutory functions.
  2. cannot be issued to direct the government on the matters in which the government has discretionary or optional power.
  3. cannot be issued for the rights of purely private in nature.
  4. cannot be issued to compel to pass an order in violation of statutory provisions.

3.Prohibition

Prohibition is issued by a higher court to prevent a lower court or tribunal to stop it from taking up a case exceeding its jurisdiction or acting contrary to the rules of natural justice. Typically this is done when the case is outside the jurisdiction of the lower court and the higher court feels that no further action should be taken on it. The higher court may take over the case after this writ has been given. Writ of prohibition is also called as preventive writ.

Writ of prohibition is issued inter alia on the following grounds,

  • Proceed to act without or excess of jurisdiction
  • Fails to exercise its jurisdiction
  • There is an error of law apparent on the face of the record in the impugned decision
  • In violation of the principles of natural justice, or
  • it proceeds to act under a law which itself invalid, ultra vires or unconstitutional, it proceeds to act in contravention of fundamental rights

4.Certiorari

Certiorari is issued by a higher court to a lower court or tribunal to review and quash the decision if it’s found to be outside the jurisdiction or in violation of principles of natural justice. When a lower court has made a decision that a higher court deems incorrect or inappropriate, this writ will often be used. The writ of certiorari allows a higher court to review the materials from the decision of a lower court with the option of reversing the decision. This can also be used in a workplace to make sure that a punishment levied by an employer against an employee is appropriate.

Grounds: Generally, the petitioner must show an error of law, excess of jurisdiction, or a violation of principles of natural justice.

5.Quo Warranto

Quo Warranto, meaning “by what authority,” is issued to inquire into the legality of a person holding a public office and to determine whether that person is qualified to hold that office. If a person claims that he has the power of a public office without any legality behind it, he is issued a quo warranto. The Court may oust a person from an office to which he is not entitled. After the writ has been given, the person must show by what authority he has asserted his claim.

This writ cannot be issued against the private institutions to hold an office of a private character.

Grounds: The petitioner questions the authority of the person holding the public office.

OTHER TYPES OF A WRIT

Writ of Procedendo

Purpose: Procedendo is issued by a higher court to a lower court, directing it to proceed with a case that it has delayed or refused to hear.

Grounds: The petitioner must show that the lower court has failed to exercise its jurisdiction.

Writ of Curative Petition:

Purpose: A curative petition is a last resort remedy to cure gross miscarriage of justice and prevent abuse of the process of law.

Grounds: The petitioner must present new evidence or arguments not considered in previous proceedings.

NOTE:

These writs vary across legal systems, and their availability might depend on the specific legal framework of a country. The specific requirements and procedures for filing writ petitions also vary.

Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp